The Zulat conference, held on 14 May 2023 at the Einav Center in Tel Aviv, included a panel entitled “What Makes Israel a Borderline Authoritarian State and When Will It Be Defined a ‘Dictatorship’?” Moderated by Neta Ahituv, the panel consisted of Prof. Daniel Bar-Tal, as well as Zulat’s Steering committee members Prof. Aeyal Gross, Dr. Meital Pinto, and Dr. Manal Totry-Jubran. Here are highlights of their remarks:
Prof. Daniel Bar-Tal: “Authoritarian elements are very prominent in Israel. There are elections, but we rank very low on democratic values. Ben-Gurion made some disastrous decisions: no education for democracy, no constitution, and he separated the ultra-Orthodox from the rest of the public and from religious Zionism. At the Friday dinner table, Israelis don’t discuss democracy with their children. The Supreme Court is not democratic: it has endorsed the Nationality Law and the occupation. The guys in the current government went a little too fast. Had they done it a la Hungary or Poland, they would have succeeded. The Israeli public does not understand what democracy is.”
Dr. Totry-Jubran: “There was never a model democracy here, but rather an ethnic democracy that gave priority to a certain public. People were shocked that a girl was beaten by a policeman on horseback during the protests, but we [Israel’s Arab citizens] have for years had deaths and overpolicing at protest events.”
Prof. Aeyal Gross: “The anti-occupation bloc in the protests is very important because it connects between the issues at stake. It’s hard for me to hear Dan ‘Light-Bump-on-the-Wing-of-the-Plane’ Halutz [he said that’s what he felt as an Air Force pilot when dropping a bomb in Gaza] and other people on the stage declaring that Israelis who don’t serve in the army are unworthy. You can’t make such a speech and then wonder why Arabs don’t join the protest.”
Dr. Meital Pinto: “We need to listen to the pain of Palestinian Arabs who are Israeli citizens and yet have minimal representation in the centers of power, to listen to those populations that live in the periphery, be it geographical or social-cultural. Everyone wants to be part of and have a share in the centers of power. Authoritarianism is very attractive because it offers a distinct sense of belonging to certain groups. It is captivating and seductive.”