The phenomenon of misinformation and disinformation lies at the heart of the democratic challenge in the current digital era. It creates a structural problem arising from the way in which the digital public sphere is organized today, via algorithmic recommendation engines, the attention economy, commercial incentives to maximize engagement, targeted advertising, coordinated influence networks, and foreign interference efforts. Within this environment, false, emotional, sensationalist, and polarizing information often enjoys a structural advantage over verified, complex, and evidence-based information. Accordingly, the democratic harm caused by false information impacts on the foundational conditions of the public discourse itself.
From the perspective of freedom of expression, this is a particularly complex challenge. When the space in which the public discourse takes place is governed by opaque mechanisms that amplify polarization and undermine public trust, the democratic promise of freedom of expression is also compromised. The central question, therefore, is not merely how to remove false content, but how to shape the operating conditions of social media platforms so that they serve an open, equal, transparent, and information-based democratic discourse.
A comparison between the European Union, the United States, and Taiwan demonstrates that there is no single model that can be adopted in its entirety. The European Union offers the most comprehensive framework currently in existence, in the form of the Digital Services Act, which is based on transparency, accountability, systemic risk assessment, and a certain degree of access for researchers. The United States, by contrast, continues to emphasize strong protection of freedom of expression against state intervention, but has a hard time addressing the structural power of online platforms and their impact on the conditions of the democratic discourse.
Taiwan offers a multi-layered, decentralized model that combines sector-specific legislation, rapid government responses, monitoring of coordinated activity, cooperation with platforms, independent fact-checking, and information literacy education. The central lesson from Taiwan’s experience is that democracy cannot confront disinformation through the state alone, and certainly not by turning the state into the ultimate arbiter of political truth.
In the Israeli context, given the country’s polarization, social divisions, security threats, and vulnerability to foreign influence, what is needed is a democratic, gradual, and carefully calibrated regulatory framework that addresses the conditions shaping public discourse, incorporates independent monitoring and oversight mechanisms, and does not rely on direct state control over content.
Academic Advisor: Prof. Amit Schejter